clock menu more-arrow no yes

2019 NFL Draft Scouting Report - QB Edition

New, 38 comments
Troy Wayrynen-USA TODAY Sports

Let’s do something a little different in this edition. I am going to dig into some of these QB prospects for the 2019 NFL Draft.

I don’t know what the future holds for Tannehill or Brock Osweiler, but I am less than optimistic. Obviously, this season has not gone the way Gase had envisioned it, specifically with Tannehill; and whether you’re a Tannehill fan or not - I think we all can agree it’s time to start looking for a young guy to groom. Which is why I believe the Dolphins need to take hard looks at these QBs in this draft. Let’s start with the consensus number 1 QB Justin Herbert.

Justin Herbert, Oregon

Herbert is my number 1 guy at the moment. He’s got the tools you look for, great intangibles, gifted athlete, strong arm, great competitor - he’s fun to watch. I think he’s got a natural arm; and what I mean by that is, his mechanics are so smooth, the ball just comes out of his hand with ease, he can float it into small windows or put zip on it when he needs to, he’s got natural talent. Now, I still need to do a lot more homework on all these QBs - but I’ve really liked what I’ve seen out of Herbert so far and believe he is worthy of the praise he is receiving.

NCAA Football: Oregon at Arizona Casey Sapio-USA TODAY Sports

Will Grier, QB, West Virginia

Grier is a smart QB with great anticipation on his throws. I don’t think he’s got the natural arm that Herbert has, but Grier can sling it. I think he’s got good zip on his throws and I like that when he is eluding pressure, his eyes are downfield. Now, almost everywhere I have seen people are complaining about his decision making and that’s a valid point, but the consistency is more of a concern to me - Grier’s play can be very exciting to watch but I need to see more of a week in week out production and results. Overall, Grier does have NFL talent and potential to be a quality starting QB in the NFL - I am excited to see how the rest of the season goes for him.

NCAA Football: West Virginia at Texas Bethany Hocker-USA TODAY Sports

Drew Lock, Missouri

Lock is a good QB with a special arm. He’s also a good athlete, competitor and can make every throw. The main concern people have with him is the fact that he beats up lesser teams and loses to more talented teams; example - loses to Georgia, South Carolina and Alabama in consecutive weeks this year. Quick take on him is I like Lock, I really do; I am just not sure how good he can get. I don’t feel like I have a good hold on him yet as a player and need to dive into more film breakdown. I do think he’s got the ability to be an NFL starter, I am just not sure where his ceiling is at yet.

NCAA Football: Missouri at Florida Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

Daniel Jones, Duke

Jones may be a lesser talked about QB prospect but he’s one of the more intriguing guys out there. He’s got great size, throws with good anticipation, has the arm strength and can make some plays with his legs. I like his toughness to stand tall in the pocket and I like his vision. I do think he needs to work on his touch; he’s got the ability to make absolutely perfect throws, he’s just not consistent. I am kind of excited about Jones and would love to see the Dolphins invest a draft pick on him.

NCAA Football: Duke at Miami Steve Mitchell-USA TODAY Sports

Thanks for reading guys. The QB position is the hardest position to scout and I have so much more work I need to do on this class, but it sure is fun. I certainly hope the Dolphin’s scouting department is doing their work on this class too because given the current state the Dolphins are in, and quite frankly have been in since Dan Marino retired, we need to be looking very closely at this QB class.

On a quick side note - I apologize for the lack of scouting reports/college coverage for this season - I have always appreciated the positive feedback and discussion from my fellow Dolphin fans. I truly am looking forward to covering the remainder of this season and hopefully get us excited for the draft and the future of our franchise. Thanks guys!