Hypothetical question for you lot. Let's say for the sake of the argument that the Dolphins have their choice of QBs, salary, draft pick trades all equal, meaning pick your favorite and explain why. I know you guys probably don't know me as I'm more of a lurker but I've been a Fins fan since about 86 and am just as depressed about the state of our beloved team as anyone.
Ok long winded explanation out of the way, so our team has the ability to pick one of these three, I'm curious as to what the consensus is.
Landry Jones> As was written here previously in comparison to our beloved hero Marino (like it or not) a top notch qb prospect who had a bit of a bad year due to a multitude of situations.
Matt Barkley> I'm personally not a fan because of my disdain for USC, USC isn't exactly know for their quality QBs. They tend to surround the qb with a boat load of talent and it makes them look better than they actually are.....examples being Sanchez, Leinart. That being said he's being talked about as a top five pick in next years draft and has been pretty impressive in his tenure at the University of Second Choice.
Ryan Tannehill> Doesn't have a lot of starts as a QB but has shown flashes of brilliance and as it is our offensive coordinator was his coach.
This is more or less to help me settle an office arguement about which way the Fins should go. Again don't go in to account what it would take to get the player, just which would you rather have and why?
Which QB do you go for?
Barkley (52 votes)
Tannehill (67 votes)
Jones (20 votes)
139 total votes