Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: NFL Players Ready To Welcome Gay Teammate

Power Ranking the NFL QBs 2.0

Aaronrodgers2-21sch5g_medium

via lilcam.edublogs.org

Now that the regular season is over, I wanted to take another look at the current starting quarterbacks around the NFL. I did one of these in the beginning of the season, and it was very successful. I wanted to take another look and see where the NFL stands now, QB wise. This listing only shows QB's that started the team's last game (week 17 or playoff). Due to this, players such as Peyton Manning and Matt Schaub are not listed. Now that the disclaimers are over, lets get to it

1. Aaron Rodgers (GB) - previously 2nd - It was between Rodgers and Brees for the first spot. I chose Rodgers because of his mobility and relative youth. He is the clear leader of the super bowl winning team, and one of the best in the game. He has led his team to almost perfection and will continue to be the best in the game

2. Drew Brees (NO) - previously 3rd - After an up and down career in San Diego, he found some stability with the Saints, and proceeded to lift the city out of the slump created by Hurricane Katrina and win the super bowl. Brees' smarts and accuracy have led him to beat Marino's record and take his place among the greatest of all time.

3. Tom Brady (NE) - previously 1st - Brady is no longer number 1, there is a new king in town. Brady is till one of the best in the game and is a QB to be feared. He shows poise in the pocket, good arm strength and pinpoint accuracy. he is starting to get up there in age, which is also attributing to his drop.

Star-divide

4. Eli Manning (NYG) - previously 10th - Eli Manning has truly taken the next step this year. Whether it is because he isn't stuck in the shadow of his brother, or if he just has some recievers that can actually catch. Whatever it is, he is now among the NFL's elite QBs. Eli is good at sensing the run, adapting, and delivering tight, accurate passes. He has also gotten rid of his interception problem from last year.

5. Matthew Stafford (DET) - previously 13th - Stafford has proved to the NFL that he is a great QB. Despite being injured previous years, he has come back to take his place among the top QBs. He has led the Detroit team very far, and they would have gone farther if they didn't play in the same division as Green Bay and played someone other the New Orleans. Stafford has a very bright future, and I wouldn't be surprised to see him rise even further.

6. Ben Roethlisberger (PIT) - previously 5th - Roethlisberger is the prototype qb of this decade. Big, strong-armed, accurate, mobile enough to extend the play, hard to hit, plays while injured. He has won multiple SBs, but is sometimes overrated because of all of the help he has recieved from his amazing defense.

7. Phillip Rivers (SD) - previously 4th - Despite an ugly release, Rivers is one of the most accurate qbs in the game. He makes the Chargers contenders every year. He makes good decisions and is a stable leader for the team to look up to. Rivers dropped his ranking this year a lot with a very poor year in a year where many qb's were having great years. His previous success is what has him this high right now.

8. Matt Ryan (ATL) - no change - After Vick's arrest, the Falcons team was left without a stable qb situation, and they drafted Matt Ryan to solve that issue. Ryan is a quiet star, and he is defined by his calmness in tense situations, earning him the nickname "Matty Ice." ATL looks to him to lead them on to multiple SB runs in the future. Ryan's stock dropped a bit because of the embarrassing loss to New York, but is still a great QB

9. Cam Newton (CAR) - previously 18th – Newton is already among the best in the NFL and has proved to be a great successor to Jake Delhomme's throne. Newton is playiing simply electric. He is ginding ways to score, whether running , or passing. He still struggles to take snaps under center, but he doesn't need to as he takes most snaps in shotgun anyways.

10. Michael Vick (PHI) - previously 6th - Vick continues to show why he is the most electric qb in the league. His speed makes the entire D confused and allows him to take apart even the best coverages. He is at the bottom end of the top 10 because he tucks and runs too much and is frequently injured because of this. After being injured for much of the season, it is turning into a huge concern with him, especially as he is getting up there in age.

11. Matt Hasselbeck (TEN) - previously 23rd – Hasselbeck has played much better than expected for the Titans, showing that he still has some fuel left in the tank. A lot of people said he wouldn't be able to have another good year,but he has proven them all wrong, almost leading the titans to the playoffs.

12. Joe Flacco (BAL) - previously 9th - Flacco had a chance to use this year to push himself into eliteness. He failed, and still remains a mere game manager. Flacco's strong arm manages a great team that looks poised to make a run now and more in the future, a future with Flacco at the helm only if he can take the reins of the team.

13. Andy Dalton (CIN) - previously 27th – Dalton is showing how he may be the perfect replacement for Palmer in Cincinnati. He had a great season, and is the franchise qb for Bengals as of now. He choked a bit in the playoffs, but should come back in a big way with a better team next year as they add another good runningback to take pressure off of his shoulders.

14. Tony Romo (DAL) - previously 16th – Romo is still a great qb, despite his team not making the playoffs. Romo needs to perform better in clutch situations, but he has all of the passing ability in the world. The cowboys should be poised to make a wildcard run next year with a better team.

15. Tim Tebow (DEN) - If you want an analysis, watch espn's NFL live, he is all they talk about, I have nothing to add.

16. Alex Smith (SF) - previously 19th – San Fran has surprised everyone this past year, and Smith is finally looking like the QB they drafted him to be. Smith rarely makes mistakes and manages the game well for the 49rs. I do think they will be big players for Peyton Manning should he be available,and Manning would lead them to the big game.

18. Josh Freeman (TB) - previously 11th - Freeman's situation was much like Flacco's this year. He should have built upon his monster year last year and gotten himself into the top 10, but he has managed to have a very bad year, which dropped his stock significantly

19. Matt moore (MIA) - Moore had to step in for an injured henne. Moore has performed admirably, putting together some great numbers. Moore should enter next season as the starter, but he will be on a very short leash. Moore is a game manager though, and that is his future if he stays the starter.

20. Kyle Orton (KC) - After being picked up by the chiefs due to Cassel's injury and Palko's suck, Orton has put together a solid end to his year. If he is resigned, he should be able to compete with cassel for the starting spot next year.

The Rest:

21. Carson Palmer (OAK)

22. Christian Ponder (MIN)

23. Mark Sanchez (NYJ)

24. John Skelton (PHO)

25. Ryan Fitzpatrick (BUF)

26. Tarvaris Jackson (SEA)

27. Blaine Gabbert (JAX)

28. Rex Grossman (WSH)

29. Seneca Wallace (CLE)

30. Josh McCown (CHI)

31. Dan Orlovsky (IND)

32. Kellen Clemens (STL)

Thanks for reading, please leave feedback in the comment section below.

This fanpost was written by one of The Phinsider's registered users.

Comment 19 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Not to be nit-picky

but I don’t think Colt McCoy played the last few games of the year. Seneca Wallace I believe started.

No disagreements with your rankings. Once you get to 15 you can jump guys around by 5 spots and nobody could argue. Moore I believe deserves to be a little higher (Josh Freeman didn’t play well this year). I would have also ranked Romo higher. I think he gets too much blame when Dallas loses and not enough credit when they win.

Good post.

Official member of "The Luck Fleet"
Nobody hurt a tackler like Zonk did.

by rintintinsoldier on Jan 17, 2012 12:14 PM EST reply actions  

That shall be fixed momentarily

Admiral of the RGIII "Robert Griffin"
Carolina OC Chudzinski for HC.
Grand Cardinal of the first holy church of brandstater

by AnishB15 on Jan 17, 2012 12:15 PM EST up reply actions  

There we go

Admiral of the RGIII "Robert Griffin"
Carolina OC Chudzinski for HC.
Grand Cardinal of the first holy church of brandstater

by AnishB15 on Jan 17, 2012 12:17 PM EST up reply actions  

Great list

Two caveats however Vick is too high and romo is too low, he had a great year after the detroit game

by Phinsphana on Jan 17, 2012 1:12 PM EST reply actions  

Top 10 is good

11-20 is a mystery though and you lost me. Freeman should drop, he had an awful year. Moore prolly should rise 1-3 spots (i’d put him one below Romo) and Tebow honestly shouldn’t be on the list at all. This is a QB ranking list and I think Tebow completed 20 passes all year. If he belongs anywhere it’s in the mid twenties with Mr. Sanchez, and even that’s being nice.

I'm ALL- IN. Do whatever it takes to get Andrew Luck or RGIII to Miami in 2012.
Laces out!
-2008 AFC East Champions-
BRANDON MARSHALL- FUTURE MIAMI HOF WR!!!!!
Tom Brandstater- more TD's than completions. Last person to tell him that's not possible, well, nobody has seen him since.

by BSerious72 on Jan 17, 2012 1:31 PM EST reply actions  

Plus I'd add TJ Yates

He actually looks very promising. I liked this kid at UNC as well. He hung tough with a couple of good games to keep the Texans alive before getting roughed up at baltimore. But let’s face it, he’s not the only one who has gotten roughed up there. I’d give him a ranking of somewhere between 15-20

I'm ALL- IN. Do whatever it takes to get Andrew Luck or RGIII to Miami in 2012.
Laces out!
-2008 AFC East Champions-
BRANDON MARSHALL- FUTURE MIAMI HOF WR!!!!!
Tom Brandstater- more TD's than completions. Last person to tell him that's not possible, well, nobody has seen him since.

by BSerious72 on Jan 17, 2012 1:32 PM EST up reply actions  

oh shit

I accidently deleted him, he goes at #17, see how there’s a blank. I will add him ASAP

Admiral of the RGIII "Robert Griffin"
Carolina OC Chudzinski for HC.
Grand Cardinal of the first holy church of brandstater

by AnishB15 on Jan 17, 2012 1:37 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

well then we'd rank him in the same area lol

I'm ALL- IN. Do whatever it takes to get Andrew Luck or RGIII to Miami in 2012.
Laces out!
-2008 AFC East Champions-
BRANDON MARSHALL- FUTURE MIAMI HOF WR!!!!!
Tom Brandstater- more TD's than completions. Last person to tell him that's not possible, well, nobody has seen him since.

by BSerious72 on Jan 17, 2012 1:46 PM EST up reply actions  

Funny how this list...

tracks kind of closely to the TEAM Power Rankings…

As someone above said, I think Romo is ranked a little low, but overall, pretty good job.

by Bill Moody on Jan 17, 2012 1:44 PM EST reply actions  

A good qb makes the rest if the team look good

Look at reggie wayne without peyton. Hes nothing.

Admiral of the RGIII "Robert Griffin"
Carolina OC Chudzinski for HC.
Grand Cardinal of the first holy church of brandstater

by AnishB15 on Jan 17, 2012 1:51 PM EST via mobile reply actions  

Reply fail

This is in response to bill moody

Admiral of the RGIII "Robert Griffin"
Carolina OC Chudzinski for HC.
Grand Cardinal of the first holy church of brandstater

by AnishB15 on Jan 17, 2012 1:52 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

I have to disagree with you about Wayne

He caught 75 passes for 960 yards and 4 TD’s. As you said without Manning. That’s better then anyone not named Marshall on our team.

"If you are what you say you are, you wouldn't have to say it."
"It's OK to be a follower, as long as you're following the right leader." – Smithology
"You Play To Win The Game" - Herman Edwards

by NawlinsPhinFan on Jan 17, 2012 4:48 PM EST up reply actions  

This list is wrong

It should read:
1. Tom Brandstater
2. All other mere mortals

I'm ALL- IN. Do whatever it takes to get Andrew Luck or RGIII to Miami in 2012.
Laces out!
-2008 AFC East Champions-
BRANDON MARSHALL- FUTURE MIAMI HOF WR!!!!!
Tom Brandstater- more TD's than completions. Last person to tell him that's not possible, well, nobody has seen him since.

by BSerious72 on Jan 17, 2012 3:20 PM EST reply actions  

yes, but i thought that was a given

I mean its not like any of these mortals are worthy of even being listed on the same page as the great ruler.

Admiral of the RGIII "Robert Griffin"
Carolina OC Chudzinski for HC.
Grand Cardinal of the first holy church of brandstater

by AnishB15 on Jan 17, 2012 3:25 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

true

I'm ALL- IN. Do whatever it takes to get Andrew Luck or RGIII to Miami in 2012.
Laces out!
-2008 AFC East Champions-
BRANDON MARSHALL- FUTURE MIAMI HOF WR!!!!!
Tom Brandstater- more TD's than completions. Last person to tell him that's not possible, well, nobody has seen him since.

by BSerious72 on Jan 19, 2012 1:19 PM EST up reply actions  

I think Matty Melt Down is overratted

Until he wins a playoff game he shouldn’t be in the top 10.

"If you are what you say you are, you wouldn't have to say it."
"It's OK to be a follower, as long as you're following the right leader." – Smithology
"You Play To Win The Game" - Herman Edwards

by NawlinsPhinFan on Jan 17, 2012 4:44 PM EST reply actions  

Matt Ryan I think is too high, like the guy above me said

Tony Romo a little too low, honestly I think Tebow is way too high. Also, I’m hesistant to put Rodgers and Brees above Tom Brady. I understand they put up bigger numbers and are more mobile and everything, but Brady and Manning have shown year after year that they can put up huge numbers (and wins) with fairly crappy offenses, whereas Brees and Rodgers didn’t start putting up huge numbers until they found an offense decked out with playmakers.

"Every island has a beach and mine there will be called Beast Beach."
Leading the drive for our new offensive coordinator: Mr. Dan Marino

by Dolphinole on Jan 17, 2012 9:48 PM EST reply actions  

Great list, thanks

The top QB’s are amazing to watch

Alex Smith really put on a show and I think he could really be on the rise.

by JImbo111 on Jan 18, 2012 10:30 AM EST reply actions  

nice work, enjoyed

a white sports coat and a pink crustacean

by a1a on Jan 19, 2012 9:49 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SB Nation's community dedicated to the only franchise in NFL history to have an undefeated team: the Miami Dolphins!

FanPosts


Head Coach

Miamidolphins_small Kevin Nogle

Coordinators

Lcffsig_small LeftCoastFinFan

Tcp_small texascowpunk

Jake_long_small kmb8488

Assistant Coaches

Kdog_medium_small Kdog92

Dan_marino1_small Finhead83

Appmichigan2_small The Earl

Miami-dolphins-rough-ipad-1024emboss_small AlejandroN