I do agree with you though. Henne just ain’t there yet and CP10 is. Everyone on that team trusts in CP10. They’ve seen him on 3rd downs, 2 minute drills, and red zones. He creates energy in the huddle when needed. His work ethic pulls teammates forward. He’s earned the right to start. If Henne can take in preseason, then sobeit- but it ain’t gonna happen.
Btw, as an aside, remember all those wildcat plays in the red zone? How do you think we GOT DOWN THERE in the first place?

I do look forward to seeing Henne LOTS (I hope) Monday. Or at least highlights, anyway.

CP10 is our guy, …….period. He had a great season last year, except for ……….our HOME playoff game……UGH !!!

That is done & over with. The Trifectia is not going to put Henne in until it is his “time” ,……period.

So for me, I’m going to sit back, relax, and let those in charge…….be in charge. This is a very exciting time to be a Dolphins fan !!!! Come on everybody,……..enjoy the ride !!!

I don’t think we needed a new thread for this again….it’s only going to start a huge debate

Matty, I’m sure your ecstatic…

Over under….550.5 comment….

I think deep down all the Pennington supporters know that me, WNY, finsx, and others are right. lol

SPOIL by Dan Marino ; )

Pennington is the better QB. That’s obvious. This Pennington vs Henne argument is stupid. Henne is the future, Pennington is now.

what can i say about this debate that hasnt been said about afghanistan, its bombed out and depleted.

If you want to take a chance in order to win them…then Henne is your guy.

If you are playing to just be average or above average then go with pennington
If you want to take a chance to be great then you go with Henne

A QB without a super strong arm who has a great trio of running backs and a dominant front line, along with a defense built to control the game, would do great things…

Griese with Csonka, Kiick, and Morris, a great front line and the No Name Defense

or

Pennington with R&R Express + Cobbs, a up-and-coming front line, and a Defense that could become a great one?

If we rush a QB into a starting situation before he is ready, both physically and psychologically, we could destroy him…see John Beck.

Maybe making Henne wait isn’t a bad thing…

ever? Can we talk about the other 70-whatever players on the roster? Here’s the reality: None of us can say what SHOULD happen, because none of us have the knowledge of what’s actually going on outside of some twitter updates during practice. Nobody has a clue how Henne handles things in meetings, what the team’s response to him is, his level of understanding in the offense, or if he’s even making the right reads in practice when he completes passes. Having Armando tell you that “Henne made a great throw on a deep out” doesn’t really back up any claims of him being ready to play. Or the future of the franchise. Or better than Pennington at this stage.

What we do know, however, is that Pennington was a big reason why we were in the playoffs last year, and his good play far outweighed the bad. I don’t understand why it’s such a bad idea to some of you for Pennington to continue to QB this team. Every single guy we’ve picked up or drafted since Marino has flopped, and now that we actually have one that DIDN’T suck, we want to chuck him aside and throw in another could-be flop? Cmon…

I actually think Henne will be very good, but I have no problems waiting for it. Especially when what we have at the moment is very good. When Henne earns his spot at the top of the depth chart, then it’ll be his time to shine. Until he proves to the coaches and the team that he’s the guy, though, we’re gonna have to sit here and wait. The 4-5 throws you see in practice don’t tell the whole story, and all of us Armchair Quarterbacks don’t have the insight into his performance to say he should be starting. I for one do not want to sacrifice a season to experiment with a QB. I’d rather wait for him to prove to our coaches that he CAN play, before he actually DOES play…

unlike most of you, i dont really care who our starting QB is, as long as we winning games and he not fucking shit up…right now i think it should be pennington’s to lose though, mainly because of the year he had last season and the way he turned this team around…Henne will get his chance, but right now it should still be penne

it’s incredibly boring and pointless. When people start saying that Pennington was only “aiight” last year, and that we will NEVER win with him as the starter, I start to fade in and out of consciousness due to the lack of intelligence spewing from the computer screen.