The Phinsider Mock Draft 4.0
We are now just over one week away from draft day. And now seems like a good time to update my mock draft for the first time in April.
1. Detroit Lions - Matthew Stafford, QB, Georgia
It's beginning to look more and more like Stafford will be Detroit's pick. And I agree with it. I think Stafford can be a franchise quarterback. He has all the physical tools you want in a quarterback. The Lions have a new coaching staff, new logo, new uniforms, and will now have a new face of their franchise.
2. St. Louis Rams - Jason Smith, OT, Baylor
The Rams took their first step towards improving their offensive line by signing center Jason Brown. They can take that next step by getting their stud left tackle to replace their previous stud left tackle, Orlando Pace, who they released earlier this offseason. Jason Smith and Eugene Monroe are the top 2 tackles in the draft. I think that Smith is a better fit for the Rams and what they want to do - be a power running team with Steven Jackson.
3. Kansas City Chiefs - Aaron Curry, LB, Wake Forest
I think that the Chiefs will go one of two ways here. They could decide to take Virginia OT Eugene Monroe and bookend him with his former college teammate, Branden Albert, who KC took in round one last year. That would make a lot of sense as well, investing in Matt Cassel's protection. But I think that KC's need for a linebacker - especially when it happens to be the draft's top defensive player - will win out here. He'll also have a damn good mentor in the recently signed Zach Thomas.
4. Seattle Seahawks - Eugene Monroe, OT, Virginia
With the signing of T.J. Houshmandzadeh, I don't see Seattle taking Crabtree here as I once thought. I don't think B.J. Raji is the pick, either, following their acquisition of Cory Redding. With OT Walter Jones getting up there in age and coming off oc microfracture surgery, investing in a top tackle has got to be a priority. Monroe is probably the least risky tackle in this draft and would be a great way to improve upon a unit that allowed 36 sacks in '08 - 13th most in the league last year.
5. Cleveland Browns - Brian Orakpo, DE/OLB, Texas
I previously thought that Malcolm Jenkins could go here because Cleveland's secondary is terrible. But his stock is falling. Meanwhile, a top pass rusher is still a need. The Browns only tallied 17 sacks in 2007 - the 2nd fewest in the league. Orakpo performed very well at his pro day - which was important following his early exit from the Combine drills. He's probably the top pass rusher available in this draft and would provide an instant upgrade as a pass rusher right off the bat.
6. Cincinnati Bengals - Andre Smith, OT, Alabama
Leave it to the Bengals to make the controversial pick in the top 10. Smith might have the most physical talent of all the tackles in the draft. But his off-the-field issues have raised some red flags. However, the Bengals must invest in protecting their franchise quarterback. Cincinnati allowed 51 sacks in '08 - the third most in the league. Smith might be a bit risky, but his talent is unquestionable. And the Bengals never seem to shy away from players who have "character red flags."
7. Oakland Raiders - Michael Crabtree, WR, Texas Tech
This would be a shame, really, for a guy like Crabtree to land in Oakland - where great potential seems to be wasted on a regular basis. And while many out there think that Al Davis needs a 40 yard dash time to draft a skill position player, I don't think he's dumb enough to pass on the draft's best receiver here. I could see Oakland deciding to sure up their interior defensive line by taking B.J. Raji here instead. But I think Al's obsession with skill positions will lead him to select the talented receiver.
8. Jacksonville Jaguars - B.J. Raji, DT, Boston College
The Jaguars need a left tackle, but the top three are already off the board. They could also use a corner, but I just don't think that the top corners deserve to be taken this high. They also need a wide receiver. But I think they can wait until their second round pick (39th overall) to fill that void. Raji makes sense here for the Jags. They lack that big, physical presence along their interior defensive line to team with John Henderson like the used to have. And that's what Raji is.
9. Green Bay Packers - Everette Brown, DE/OLB, Florida State
The Packers are switching to a 3-4 defensive scheme this offseason and the team lacks that classic 3-4 pass-rushing outside linebacker. Brown is just that - a true pass rusher. A lot of people think a corner could go here, but I just don't see that as a higher priority than a pass rusher. After all, the 3-4 simply doesn't work without pass-rushing linebackers.
10. San Francisco 49ers - Michael Oher, OT, Mississippi
While many will make a case for Mark Sanchez landing in San Francisco, but I just don't see it. I'm torn here between a pass-rushing OLB like Aaron Maybin and a right tackle that they can pair with Joe Staley as bookends for the foreseeable future. And while the Niners did sign Marvel Smith, it's very risky to count on a guy who has missed 16 games over the past 2 seasons.
11. Buffalo Bills - Aaron Maybin, DE, Penn State
The Bills need a pass rusher and Maybin, having recently turned 21, has a ton of upside.
12. Denver Broncos - Mark Sanchez, QB, USC
Sanchez would be an ideal fit to run the kind of offense that Josh McDaniels will be installing in Denver.
13. Washington Redskins - Brian Cushing, LB, USC
Would be an ideal fit replacing the recently released Marcus Washington at OLB.
14. New Orleans Saints - Malcolm Jenkins, CB, Ohio State
The Saints still need secondary help and Jenkins could play either corner or safety in New Orleans.
15. Houston Texans - Clay Matthews, LB, USC
The "Matthews" name is like royalty in Houston. Oh - and they happen to need a solid linebacker to play along side DeMeco Ryans.
16. San Diego Chargers - Rey Maualuga, LB, USC
Maualuga is the reliable inside linebacker that the Chargers have been looking for who can step right in and have a positive impact on San Diego's defense.
17. New York Jets - Josh Freeman, QB, Kansas State
The Jets need offensive firepower through the air. A wide receiver would be the pick, but I think Freeman offers NY too much value to pass up on - especially when your current quarterbacks are not very good.
18. Denver Broncos - Tyson Jackson, DE, LSU
The Broncos need help in their front seven as they make the switch to a 3-4 and Jackson is the prototypical 3-4 defensive end.
19. Tampa Bay Bucs - Michael Johnson, DE, Georgia Tech
The Bucs need more help on their defensive line. Their starter opposite of Gaines Adams is the aging Kevin Carter. Johnson is a guy with tremendous physical ability and Raheem Morris is just the coach to tap into all that talent.
20. Detroit Lions - Eben Britton, OT, Arizona
Having gotten their franchise QB with their first pick, investing in protecting that QB makes a lot of sense.
21. Philadelphia Eagles - Knowshon Moreno, RB, Georgia
Brian Westbrook isn't getting any younger and he's always been a "fragile" back. With Correll Buckhalter now in Denver, the Eagles need a guy who can compliment their aging star RB.
22. Minnesota Vikings - Jeremy Maclin, WR, Missouri
The Vikings could use a RT, but the top 5 tackles are gone already. So they take the biggest playmaker remaining on the board.
23. New England Patriots - Donald Brown, RB, Connecticut
Let's just chalk this pick up to a "hunch" I have. I will say, though, that I strongly feel that Brown is the second best back in this draft, trailing only Moreno.
24. Atlanta Falcons - Brandon Pettigrew, TE, Oklahoma St.
Atlanta has a hole at tight end and Pettigrew is the draft's best all-around TE. He'll block well for Michael Turner and will provide a reliable target for Matt Ryan.
25. Miami Dolphins - Darius Butler, CB, Connecticut
I'll admit it - this is the first year in a while where I'm completely stumped on what the Dolphins will do with their first round pick. It's that wide open - and Bill Parcells never lets any info leak out. We all know that the Dolphins could go in a variety of directions here - with CB, OLB, and WR the three most likely. So why do I think Butler is now the guy?
I just don't think Bill Parcells and Jeff Ireland will spend a first round pick on a WR when it's known that Bill thinks receivers are "a dime a dozen." There is some good value at the receiver position in rounds 2 through 4 this year. And I don't think any remaining outside linebacker on the board is worthy of the 25th pick. Butler, meanwhile, has the ability to come right in and battle for the starting corner job opposite Will Allen. He has the best footwork of all the corners in the draft. He also probably possesses the best change of direction ability of all the corners. And his 43 inch vertical makes up for his lack of ideal size - though he certainly isn't short at 5'10 and a half.
26. Baltimore Ravens - Vontae Davis, CB, Illinois
Davis has unquestioned talent. It's his character and work ethic that some worry about - though I'm not particularly concerned myself.
27. Indianapolis Colts - Peria Jerry, DT, Mississippi
The Colts have an obvious need at defensive tackle and Jerry is a steal this late in round one.
28. Philadelphia Eagles - William Beatty, OT, Connecticut
The Eagles have a hole to fill following the departure of Tra Thomas and Beatty could step in and man the left tackle spot right from the get go.
29. New York Giants - Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR, Maryland
The Giants have a clear need at wide receiver right now and, while a player like Hakeem Nicks or Kenny Britt might fit their style better, Heyward-Bey provides better draft value for the Giants.
30. Tennessee Titans - Robert Ayers, DE, Tennessee
I think the Titans will hold off on taking a wide receiver and address their defensive line. Javon Kearse is aging and not as productive as he once was while Kyle Vanden Bosch had some injury issues last year.
31. Arizona Cardinals - Chris Wells, RB, Ohio State
Wells is the ultimate wildcard in terms of where he could be drafted in round one. If he does make it this far, there's no way the Cards pass on him - teaming him with Tim Hightower in their backfield.
32. Pittsburgh Steelers - Max Unger, G/C, Oregon
The Steelers surrendered too many sacks last year. They have to protect their franchise quarterback - who has taken a beating the past couple of years. Unger provides position flexibility along their offensive line.
So there is my latest mock draft. I'll update it one more time next week and then see how I fare.
Share your thoughts below...
46 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
FIRST
Not bad Matty, i like this one. This mock draft is probably what teams are Going to do not what they should do b/c in my mind there is no reason Matt Stafford should be the first pick in the draft he is just not that good
Official Leader Of The Draft Hakeem Nicks Club
by jazztrumpeter89 on Apr 17, 2009 12:32 AM EDT reply actions
I disagree
knowshon might have gotten alot of the spot light last season but Matt Stafford was a solid scary fella for Georgia, he’s faced tough staunch defenses in the SEC and proved that he has what it takes to win games in his spot. aside from Tebow being the number one QB in the SEC, one can arguably say Stafford was the number Two man.
I agree mostly Matty
what my hunch is and will shake things up a bet is seattle falling in love with Sanchez and that would be a great fit for the guy. This moves Monroe down and the other two top LT’s. that would be interesting and might throw a OLB to us… I also think because of the shorage Ayers goes higher alot higher. I do hope M. Johnson does go to TB that would push another down and keep us from picking the guy :)
25th pick - Clay Mathews LB USC
44th pick - Alphonso Smith cb Wake Forest
56th pick - Clint Sintim LB Virginia
86th pick - Fili Moala DT USC
Interesting
I don’t know that I’ve ever seen you participate in a mock where both Butler and Davis are available and you opt for the former..
Have you had a change of heart? Is there something you see in Butler that now causes you to value him slightly above Davis? I’m sure the margin isn’t terribly wide..but I wouldn’t mind knowing what’s up with that.
I think that if both Butler and Davis were on the board...
that Parcells would rather take the high character guy. But I wouldn’t be shocked if they went Davis because he’s more physical.
Davis or Butler
The problem with Davis is that there are too many question marks with him, is he motivated?, if so why was he benched mid season , is he all potential that wont materialize at the next level like his brother Vernon…on the other hand Butler ‘s stock seems to keep going up with NFL’s Mike Mayock saying that he’s heard from scouts that Butler’s proday work out was the best they had EVER seen for a corner back…
McShay
has us taking our boy Britt in round 1… wow!
25. Miami Dolphins (11-5): Kenny Britt, WR, Rutgers
Top three needs: CB, WR, NT
It will be interesting to see if Bill Parcells drafts an offensive skill player, which traditionally has not been his style. There is no arguing Miami’s need for a wideout opposite Ted Ginn Jr., and Britt is climbing up a lot of draft boards with his combination of size, strong hands and better-than-expected top-end speed.
Id be really surprised if this is the pick… he has Nicks going AFTER Britt.. not sure about that, as much as I love Britt.
post link to mayock's mock
please
25th pick - Clay Mathews LB USC
44th pick - Alphonso Smith cb Wake Forest
56th pick - Clint Sintim LB Virginia
86th pick - Fili Moala DT USC
its mcshay not mayock
and u need espn insider to view..http://insider.espn.go.com/nfl/draft09/insider/columns/story?columnist=mcshay_todd&id=4054682
oo my eyes playing tricks
I like mcsay but in that mock he has us passing on Mau with baltimore taking him. I would like to see mayock’s I think he is one of if not the the best talent evaluator out there
25th pick - Clay Mathews LB USC
44th pick - Alphonso Smith cb Wake Forest
56th pick - Clint Sintim LB Virginia
86th pick - Fili Moala DT USC
couldnt go wrong with either one,
"How can I blame you
When it's me I can't forgive?"
-From the Unforgiven III off of Death Magnetic
I i would agree with that...
I LOVE Nicks, but i wouldn’t mind Britt either. He reminds me of Marques Colston, same body type, and skill set, but if we do go this route, and take Butler, Nicks may be long gone before we pick again, so my boy ROBISKIE would be there!!!
Now is the time- the time to rise up from the depths of Hell and stake our claim back on top of the AFC East...Look out Gaytriots here comes Jake Long and the Phins
Very Good Mock Matty!!!
Now is the time- the time to rise up from the depths of Hell and stake our claim back on top of the AFC East...Look out Gaytriots here comes Jake Long and the Phins
I almost had the exact draft
I like your Viking pick and you have WR falling, in the 1st. If Maclin goes past Jacksonville this could happen! IMO I do not think the Pats will go RB, but I really like Butler over Davis for the Fins. Davis’s ability stands out, but I think he is a work out warrior like his brother, and has character question.
Only other thing is the Giants I think they go Kenny Britt even with Bay left. I think Bay will be a big 1st round bust, and may be picked by the Ravens.
Gurantee at least two first round picks get swapped in draft day trades.
The Patriots Suck
My explanation about Donald Brown
Here’s why I have Brown to NE at 23. In the media mock draft competition that I’m hoping to get into, you’re scored like this: 1 point for the correct round for each player and 2 points for matching the player with the correct team. So even if Brown goes to NE with their first 2nd round pick, I’ll get 2 points instead of the maximum 3 for that pick.
So why am I convinced Brown will go to NE. Assuming another team doesn’t take him before NE can, my brother personally knows Donald Brown’s father. And last week, when they were talking, his father told my brother than the Pats told Donald that they really like him and there’s a good chance they will take him at some point.
I like it
I was basing it off WEEI here in Boston, a reliable source doesn’t think RB will go to the Pats in round 1. But your reasoning makes lots of sense for the scoring. I don’t like the Pats being in front of the Fins cause they need a CB and OLB and could take away the Fins options.
The Patriots Suck
They could take a LB
Their defense could use some youth.
"How can I blame you
When it's me I can't forgive?"
-From the Unforgiven III off of Death Magnetic
Agreed
I’m almost convinced we go with one of the two at 25
by Dave.Phuller on Apr 19, 2009 2:49 AM EDT up reply actions
Nice Job!
I see Kansas City going with Eugene Monroe.
KC’s defense has huge needs, but there are linebackers available in the later rounds.
I see KC’s identity now tied up with Matt Cassel, LJ, Bowe, and an improved O-Line.
Having Monroe and Albert will be crucial to that.
Seattle takes Aaron Curry and the rest of the draft goes as you figured out.
I think that New England takes Darius Butler for all the reasons you stated. I just hope the Trio takes Sean Smith instead of Vontae Davis.
I think that Donald Brown falls to Arizona and the Giants take Britt instead of Heyward-Bey (if they don’t make the deal for Braylon Edwards)
Robert Ayers to the Titans is dead on.
I think the Steelers take Mack instead of Unger.
Joining the "Draft Sean Smith in the First Round" Bandwagon even though he could lift 225 lbs only 10 times
I would be disappointed in Butler at #25
If you want to defend the pass, rush the passer and stop the run. Those are bigger needs IMO. The phins need to find 2 pass rushers for this year. If Wake is one of them, then they need one more. Porter can’t do it by himself.
The phins are also soft in the middle when stopping the run. Baltimore dominated them last year in the playoffs. The front 7 of the phins defense couldn’t stand up to it. This year they are playing a bunch of teams that will run it down your throat if you let them.
For months on this site I have read comment after comment, post after post, about how this “FO likes to build from the inside out” meanning OL and DL / LB. “Build the foundation first.” But now with the draft looming, everyone wants to take a CB or a WR at #25. Why? When did they solve their front 7 problems on defense, especially at ILB and NT?
I say draft LB’s and lots of them, IMO, they have 1.5 LB’s now (Porter = 1, Crowder =0.5). And you need 4. Pittsburgh has 2 outstanding OLB’s and 2 above average ILB’s. That is where the phins need to get too.
Based on Matty's draft
Who would you take with the 25th pick? If there is not a OLB or MLB or DT the FO finds worthy of a 1st round grade why would you pick a player lower on your board. James Lauranitis is the only LB I may take that seems left on the board, but the key word is Might!
The Patriots Suck
Honestly, if the draft goes the way Matty
describes above, I guess the phins would have to take Butler. That draft board above would almost represent the worst case scenario for the phins. English, Barwin, Ayers, or Lauranitis are 2nd round picks IMO, so I guess that leaves Butler.
But if any of these guys are available at #25 I would take them over any CB in the draft: Curry, Matthews, Cushing, Maybin, Brown, Orakpo, Maualuga.
I think everyone would agree on that
But I was saying if the draft was to go as posted, then Butler would be my pick
The Patriots Suck
I'll pass on Cushing
But if they took Matthews, Brown, or Maybin, I’d be ok with it.
Curry won’t last past pick 5.
No more draft talk....cant....take.....much.............more.
Phinsider Hall of Fame Class of 2009
2-Time Matty Award Winner
Matthew
u know im jokin…..im just so friggin ready for the draft. I think it has to do with this being my 1st real offseason on this site….and in my entire life i have never talked the draft this in depth…normally it would be in my head…now i have all you knuckleheads to bounce crap off….its like the kid a week before christmas…i wanna go to sleep till its time.
maybe a case of nyquil will do it? lol…someone just pour cold water on my in bed when its 4pm on sat next week.
but i would like to say Matty you do a helluva job making things make sense….that pressure points post was dyn -o-mite
Phinsider Hall of Fame Class of 2009
2-Time Matty Award Winner
haha
dyn-o-mite, huh?
Yeah – at this point, I wish I had that remote control from the movie “Click” so I could just fast forward through this next week.
lol...yea but Sandler totally didnt use that remote the way i woulda.....
Phinsider Hall of Fame Class of 2009
2-Time Matty Award Winner
LB's
Don’t forget that we have Matt Roth. Last year, he thought that he was going to play defensive end and weighed 275 lbs. This year he hopefully will reduce his weight while maintaining his strength. We will draft LB’s, but we need to draft a corner first because there are only a few top quality CB’s in this draft and we cannot wait for day two and get caught drafting nickel and dime backs.
agree
I agree with the position with the 25th pick. … just not sure who the player is as it depends who is there (Jenkins is said to be falling hard, Davis could be there, Butler, or even stretch a bit for the taller Sean Smith?) The only way I don’t see it being a corner is if a LB falls into their laps!
If it is a corner in round 1, in my mind, the ideal situation is to go with NT (Brace … if there) with 2A and follow it up with a LB (such as SIntim), a WR (such as Robiskie) or another corner (Moore or A. Smith perhaps) with 2B.
The second round almost seems more important to me in some way. I guess that the quality of players seems very close between #25 and our 2nd rounders.
good mock matty
but the Michael Johnson pick would be a bit of a reach to say the least. He may sneak in at the end of the 1st round but thats as close as he’ll get. Guys like Robert Ayers and Peria Jerry should be the pick for Tampa.
I wouldn't take Johnson in round 1
But there’s been a handful of reports that claim the Bucs are really doing their H/W on Johnson. And all it will take is for them to fall in love with his upside and physical talent.
Looks like there will be some major changes to this mock next week...
…following the Bills trade of Jason Peters to Philly.
Yae Matty
I am thinking Sanchez goes to seattle IF that happens that very well could push Oher to Bills and leave a pass rusher for us shrugs
25th pick - Clay Mathews LB USC
44th pick - Alphonso Smith cb Wake Forest
56th pick - Clint Sintim LB Virginia
86th pick - Fili Moala DT USC
Nice job
I like your mock draft. You did a great job. =)
Dolphins. They think they're so cute. Oh, look at me, I'm a flippy little dolphin, let me flip for you.
by The Dolphins Are Coming on Apr 17, 2009 4:23 PM EDT reply actions
Browns
since it seems they will def trade edwards…..most new mock drafts have them taking crabtree…and it makes allot of sense…with winslow and braylon gone they would have no choice. stalloworth situation hurts them even more…if u ask me if crabtree is on the board they take him 100%
Phinsider Hall of Fame Class of 2009
2-Time Matty Award Winner
trade with st louis our qb from michigan & our #1 get the very best qb in years
we can structure a deal with st louis im sure if we try hard enough maybe out think the jets management again acouple of players acouple of picks whatever it takes if detroit does not take stafford. buddy up st louis get this done, theirs great oppertunity here lets walk all over these nfl teams
by wild zion beaver on Apr 19, 2009 1:13 AM EDT reply actions

by 




















