Why We Should Not Draft a Wide Receiver on Day 1.
One increasingly popular opinion amongst Dolfans, as well as the mainstream sports media, is that The Dolphins receiving corps is an area of weakness that should be addressed in the first day, if not the first round, of the draft. When mentioned in the same sentence as Miami or one of its receivers, the phrase "True #1" is usually paired up with a negative adverb or adjective such as "no", "not", or "lacking". This article will help dispel the myths surrounding our excellent talent.
As all Phinsiders know, Greg Camarillo has transitioned from a winless-season-saving hero, to a fearless and dependable, over-the-middle receiver with fantastic hands. During the first 12 games, he was Pennington's go to guy on clutch 3rd downs. The torn ACL is the only thing that raises any question marks about his playing ability, but from recent reports, it sounds like he is having a speedy recovery.
Ted Ginn drastically improved upon his 2007 performance. Who can forget that amazing over-the-shoulder grab at the very back of the end zone vs. Seattle? That's just a little flash of what things will be like in 2010. Ginn's skills lie in his ability to get over the top of the secondary; a receiver like that can only do so much with a QB like Chad Pennington. As Sparano pointed out, Ginn's lack of receptions was due to the way he was used. Drafting another receiver that can burn the secondary will not make Pennington's arm any stronger.
Next up, Brandon London. This kid did not get a lot of playing time on offense, but Brandon made a heck of an impression when he did. His diving catch converted a clutch 3rd down during the most important game of the entire season, versus the hated Jets no less. That is the definition of performing under pressure. When taken into account that Brandon stands at an impressive 6'4", and he has a great work ethic, it seems he is just a season away from being the end zone threat that Ernest Wilford was supposed to be.
As an UDFA out of Hawaii, Davone Bess is a Rags-to-Riches type story--going from prison in high school to the NFL. When Greg Camarillo went down for the season, Davone stepped up immediately recording 5 receptions for 87 yards vs. NE in his first ever NFL start. He followed that up with two strong performances against St. Louis and Buffalo where Bess caught 6 passes for 84 yards and 9 passes for 74 yards, respectively. Just to put this into perspective, Greg Camarillo started 11 games and only had 3 games over 70 yards, and only one of those was for 80 plus. Davone did it in his first three. As the season got colder, and The Dolphins played in frostbitten cities like KC and "New York", Davone had 15 receptions for 121 yards to close out the regular season. In his first 6 NFL starts, Davone Bess totaled 35 catches for 366 yards, which is an average of 10.5 yards per catch. These weren't all great passes either; the name Bess conjures an image of an acrobatic, mid-air twist to snag an errant pass that was thrown well behind him. Bess may not be as tall as Larry Fitzgerald, but he definitely has the hands and the agility to make similar awe-inspiring grabs.
It's time for some more perspective; Davone's first season stacks up nicely against the rookie years of two of the NFL's greatest receivers--Terrell Owens and Larry Fitzgerald. Terrell Owens started 10 of the 16 games he played in San Francisco and he caught 35 passes for 520 yards with Steve Young at QB. In 2004 Larry Fitzgerald started all 16 games and had 58 receptions for 780 yards. Davone Bess started in 6 of 16 games and he recorded a total of 54 receptions for 554 yards. When his average of just under 6 receptions per start is extrapolated to a full season, Davone may have caught 93 passes for 975 yards. Those are pretty astounding numbers considering that wide receivers normally take 2-3 years to develop.
Davone Bess can make people miss, so the 10.5 average yards per catch (as well as the averages of Camarillo and Ginn) can be attributed to Pennington's weak arm. Pennington only averaged 7.7 yards per completion and this was his second highest season average (not including 2000 where he only had 2 completions), just barely falling short of his 7.8 average in 2002. When the ball takes so much longer to reach it's target, it is more likely that a defensive back is going to be there as soon as a receiver makes the grab. Pennington's lack of a bullet brings down the average of the entire receiving corps.
To sum up: Davone Bess has the numbers and the heart to be our "True #1" wide receiver and, when Henne takes over in 2010 or mid/late 2009, Ted Ginn will be a deep threat that defenses must account for with their #1 Corner or with double coverage. Also, Greg Camarillo is a great slot receiver, and Brandon London is developing into a physical end zone threat. Taking all of this into account, it just does not make sense for The Phins to draft a wide receiver on Day 1.
This fanpost was written by one of The Phinsider's registered users.
0 recs |
37 comments
Comments
I agree that the Phins don't need to invest a day one pick on a WR...
but Davonne Bess as our #1, I’m not ready to believe that yet.
I think there were some games where he was shut down by the other team’s defense.
The evidence of a #1 is that he cannot be shut down by one-on-one coverage.
I don’t see other teams doubling Bess to stop our passing game.
Joining the "Draft Sean Smith in the First Round" Bandwagon even though he could lift 225 lbs only 10 times
by DolphDallas on Apr 12, 2009 3:21 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
In the 6 games Bess started,
he had 1 game where he only had 3 receptions. Terrell Owens had 6 games this year with 3 or fewer receptions. Larry Fitzgerald had 2 games. Santonio Holmes had 8.
by joel311 on Apr 12, 2009 3:34 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I see Henne starting at some point this year
Its not that i think pennington will get benched, I just doubt his ability to stay healthy very long.
Ted Ginn is the man.
by topspin on Apr 12, 2009 7:32 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Devone Bess is what he is...a nice story who had a nice year AFTER...
…Camarillo went down. My guess is he will never post those numbers again in his career. He’s a slot WR at best, and not even the best slot WR on this team.
I don’t understand where everyone gets this “he makes people miss” thing from. I understand that was something that Sparano was saying last year, but I didn’t see it.
The guy obviously has a lot of heart, but he definitely in NOT a #1, or even a starting caliber WR.
I don’t care what the Front Office is saying about how they like our WR’s. Actions speak louder than words. If they don’t take a WR in the first 3 rounds, I’ll believe it. If they do, then you know they were spouting BS and just taking the company line.
by dab415217 on Apr 12, 2009 3:45 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Sparano was saying it?
I just saw it for myself on his kick returns and his receptions anytime he had room to move.
by joel311 on Apr 12, 2009 4:22 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
All that info you have stated above
just proves the point that we have no true #1reciever. I think Nicks and Britt are the only guys that can be that at our positions in the draft. And that garbage that bess is a #1 is just plain stupid. Maybe he can be like Wes Welker but not a Randy Moss. I think if we keep Ronnie and we have Nicks/Britt lined up opposite of ginn, then we have an offense that will actually strike fear into our opponents.
Plus i think our FO WILL go with a wide receiver on day one because they want to supply as many weapons they can to Henne. Look what Cassel was able to do with that offense he had at NE, dont you think if Henne had a guy anywhere close to randy moss he could put up the same numbers as Cassel did at NE. I honestly think this FO wants to do all they can to setup Henne with a good offense.
by jazztrumpeter89 on Apr 12, 2009 4:28 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
You are dreaming.
You are not going to draft a receiver and have them perform as a number 1 in their first year. Randy Moss is just a freak exception. Using draft picks like lottery tickets is just a good way to set the organization back in time.
by joel311 on Apr 12, 2009 5:09 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
what are you talking about dude...never post those numbers again really
Not a starting caliber WR…..? You probably said that about Wes Welker too….the guy was a rookie steped up and played real well for us last year.He may not be our number 1…but i aint got no problem with him as our number 2 and ofcourse slot.
by drey34 on Apr 12, 2009 4:31 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
On and on with the Bess Bandwagon.....
I think Bess will end up as our #1. He is young with good speed and hands. I believe he is going to be much better than Camarillo. With this though, I also believe that Ted Ginn should go back to sole returning duty (the same with Devin Hester) and we should, without a doubt grab a late round running back.
by xiola20 on Apr 12, 2009 4:46 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
why
would we draft a RB in late rounds???we did that $#!t last year and got 2 of them for our practice squad..
IMO we are pretty good with the RB situation, maybe trade Rickey for a #3 to a desperate team. Cobbs would be a great 3rd dwn back..
Yes Bess does make people miss i ve watched it with my own eyes, he will be alot more than a nice story for last year
I hope Camarillo makes it back healthy,he was saying how much pain he was in and how much he respects ronnine for doing what he did after having the same injury
A feeding frenzy is about to take place in the dirty south
by FinfanT on Apr 12, 2009 7:06 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
i want them to draft a reciever at 25. if we pass on him and hes there at 44. you thank the heavens and draft him.
not gonna say his name because that’d be “obnoxious”
II believe in John Beck and that Cbdolphin is the man. Most Comments in one Thread- total count = 1,300
Official Leader of the Draft Kenny Britt Bandwagon
Longest Sig In the History of Phinsider belongs to Me. 53 Lines in Total.
Check it out.
Front Paged - Class of 08. and 09.
by finsxfactor on Apr 12, 2009 5:38 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
If we can land him at 44
I’d be perfectly fine with that
by Dave.Phuller on Apr 12, 2009 6:37 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
(extends hand). pray with me?
II believe in John Beck and that Cbdolphin is the man. Most Comments in one Thread- total count = 1,300
Official Leader of the Draft Kenny Britt Bandwagon
Longest Sig In the History of Phinsider belongs to Me. 53 Lines in Total.
Check it out.
Front Paged - Class of 08. and 09.
by finsxfactor on Apr 12, 2009 6:41 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think CB is our #1 priority
There is so much depth at Wide Receiver, I think Britt will be there for sure at 44. We can get away without a huge play receiver for another year. Pennington’s arm only goes so far. If we get a Cornerback that will fill the huge HOLE. WR and LB are places that can be UPGRADED. Thats why I think that we address CB first. I also think Nose tackle is a pretty big issue.
Ted Ginn is the man.
by topspin on Apr 12, 2009 7:38 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I agree
the ceilings of all four recievers have yet to be reahed and unless something crazy happens draft day no WR will be picked in the first 4 rounds
25th pick - Clay Mathews LB USC
44th pick - Alphonso Smith cb Wake Forest
56th pick - Clint Sintim LB Virginia
86th pick - Fili Moala DT USC
by Blaze453 on Apr 12, 2009 6:23 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Good work
but I disagree with you. Camarillo is nice WR, but he’s not a number 1. Saying he was Pennington’s go to guy only shows that the guy knows how to get open underneath. Camarillo isn’t even the best slot WR on the team.
London, as much as I like him, I don’t know if he can be a true go-to guy. He has some size and leaping ability, and he has good hands, but he doesn’t have the speed to stretch the defense, or the RAC ability to anything once he makes the catch. He’s a solid redzone threat and good guy to set up some favorable matchups.
Ginn is a speed merchant, but he’s just not the all-around playmaker you want out of your number 1 target. You’re right that his strength lies in his ability to get behind the defense, but saying this
Drafting another receiver that can burn the secondary will not make Pennington’s arm any stronger.
is pointless, because Pennington won’t be the QB after this season, and we shouldn’t be drafting players to fit his style. Another speedy WR would do wonders to our offense when Henne steps in because you’ll see more and more 2deep safeties, thanks to the threat of 2 WR’s going by the corner, and Henne hitting the bomb for a TD.
Bess, I agree, is a great story, and can be a terrific WR, but to compare him to TO and Larry Fitzgerald is a mistake IMO. Bess isn’t going by people on deep balls, muscling them off him on a crossing route, or outleaping a CB and FS on the same play for a big gain. He’s a reliable target who will catch anything in his radius, and he’s able to do some things once the ball is in his hands. I think the best way to use him is in the slot, because he’ll out-quick a safety, and out-run a LB, so teams will need to play a nickel set to properly match up.
Overall, I still see the need for a gamebreaker like Harvin or Nicks. We need a guy who can do it all, make the big third down grab in traffic, beat the jam and go by the CB, take a screen to the house, and turn a 10 yard Dig into a 35 yard gain. If you have a whole bunch of guys that are only good at one or two things, teams will just play you according to the situation (i.e. slide the coverage to Bess on 3rd and Short..) and try to take away the “go-to” guy for that particular play. Harvin/Nicks will be a threat in any situation, and it will not only force the defense to play honest, but will also open up the other WR’s to do the things they do best. Davone Bess or Ted Ginn are not keeping me from taking a WR on day 1.
by Little Nicky 21 on Apr 12, 2009 10:10 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
THANK YOU NICKY
I agree with everything you just said and i will probably never have to write a lot as long as ur around. thanks
by jazztrumpeter89 on Apr 12, 2009 10:24 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
lol
you can still write though :-)
by Little Nicky 21 on Apr 12, 2009 10:43 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I never claimed Camarillo was a number 1.
by joel311 on Apr 14, 2009 12:53 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
didn't say you did
Just pointed out that none of our WR’s are every-situation go-to guys, somebody you can look to at any time and get the ball to.
by Little Nicky 21 on Apr 14, 2009 3:20 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Agreed with Little Nicky...
However, i don’t think a guy like Harvin is best for this team…Hakeem Nicks is everything that this receiver core is lacking…also, i think he will be able to start right away and make a huge contribution…Unless Maulauga is there at 25, get Nicks cause he wont be there at 44
by scbrandon on Apr 12, 2009 10:40 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
For discussion's sake
why not Harvin? What’s your take on him, and why don’t you think he’d be right for the team?
by Little Nicky 21 on Apr 12, 2009 10:43 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
i think harvin fits
and he could play at WR, RB, and QB(wildcat baby) the fact that he can play anywhere makes him special. You want to see the wildcat formation really skyrocket put harvin back there and watch him run.
If we draft him i wont be mad, but like scbrandon said i think Nicks is probably better for the team because he is a very good WR, harvin is a good WR but the fact that he can take it to the house is why he is rated so high.
by jazztrumpeter89 on Apr 12, 2009 10:58 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
right
I got Nicks rated higher than Harvin, but I won’t disappointed with either of them over the other.
The biggest difference is that Harvin’s stock is dropping a bit and he probably will make it to 44, while Nicks could drop into the second, but may not make it 12 picks in. If we don’t take one of them in the 1st, Harvin will be the more likely guy to drop to us in the second.
by Little Nicky 21 on Apr 12, 2009 11:07 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
The only 2 knocks on him are his size and his durability issues
of course you can say he has “character issues” because of the weed thing but thats goiing a bit overboard,
"How can I blame you
When it's me I can't forgive?"
-From the Unforgiven III off of Death Magnetic
by Patssuck456 on Apr 13, 2009 8:08 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
My take
Harvin is the playmaker this WR corp is lacking. Durability is my biggest question mark about him. He was used and abused in that spread formation. Half the highlights from Mattys post was him taking a handoff….and while I give him credit because you can see tough kid in him,it just looked like he took a beaten. Nicks seems more polished and just the type of WR that this FO is looking for. Looking at those highlights of Nicks did remind me of Michael Irvin.With the depth at CB in this years draft class….I can see the FO taking the BPA (OLB or WR)
by drey34 on Apr 12, 2009 11:01 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
can't really argue with that
except even though Harvin did run the ball quite a bit, he didn’t take a huge beating inside like you would expect a RB to take. He’s strong enough to take the abuse as a WR, and I don’t envision us using him out of the backfield much, so his ability to take the RB pounding shouldn’t be an issue. He reminds me of Steve Smith in the way that he isn’t scared of contact and he’s willing to put his shoulder down and truck somebody.
by Little Nicky 21 on Apr 12, 2009 11:09 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Im worried about the punishment he already has taken
What exactly was the extent of his injuries?? I think he can be the best WR of the bunch but can he stay on the fieldb? He wont be trucking everyone in the pros
by drey34 on Apr 12, 2009 11:19 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
The biggest issue for me with Harvin is....
his durability…Almost every week he was a gametime decision. In the NFL he will need to be healthy mostly because of the transition to the NFL he will need to get all the practice time he can get and everyone knows that Sparano feels that if you don’t practice well you don’t play…Hence Ernest Wilford..also, if you watch the video, Nicks was never tackled by the first defender…It always takes atleast 2, and sometimes up to 5 guys to take him down. Nicks was also a team captain and runs cleaner routes than Harvin so the transition to the NFL would not be as bad as some other unpolished receivers….
by scbrandon on Apr 13, 2009 12:19 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
or he gets to the endzone untouched
about the durability thing why did our FO go out and get Jake Grove then. They got him because he works hard and is an absolute beast. I would take Nicks over Harvin but Harvin as a pick is not bad. He will stay healthier by not having to play RB and our staff seems to do an excellent job keeping the dolphins in amazing shape. SO if Harvin comes here maybe those durability issues wont be a problem with the workouts our team enforces plus no RB for him anymore.
by jazztrumpeter89 on Apr 13, 2009 12:26 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I have to agree there
durability shouldn’t be much of an issue in the NFL because he won’t be getting 30 touches a game and running between the tackles at all. Good point about the strength and conditioning program, I’ve never seen a Dolphins team as healthy throughout the season as last year’s squad, and I think that says a lot about how the culture changed and the conditioning improved.
by Little Nicky 21 on Apr 13, 2009 12:58 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I know he's a work in progress to say the least
BUT our very own Todd Lowber is 6’3" 205 and runs the 40 in 4.1 but he didn’t start playing “organized” Football until 2006 so I’m sure he’a quite raw but if this kid develops nicely..LOOK OUT!
I feel BP likes smashmouth much more than me, because I’m more of a “spreadem’ out 5 wide and cover us if ya can biches!” kind of guy, but I truly feel we have the makings of a VERY explosive WR corp and when our badass OL gets comfortable with each other and the R&R Express gets chugging we will have the pieces of a darn good Offense NOW so I don’t think we will draft WR especially early but if they go WR,WR,WR,WR I’ll just laugh and say “spreadem’ out 5 wide and cover us if ya can biches!”.
BTW..I really like Armstrong too .
by haildanhenningnow on Apr 13, 2009 3:57 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Wow,
had no idea Lowber owned 4.1-40 speed. That’s insane; I don’t recall ever seeing a player run a sub-4.3-40, nevermind a 4.1. With that kind of frame and that kind of speed, this kid could be a monster when it all starts to click..
by Dave.Phuller on Apr 13, 2009 8:32 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Me neither
but I was trying to find Armstrongs 40 time and found this:
and the second article(at the bottom of the page) on this site is more informative IMO
by haildanhenningnow on Apr 13, 2009 2:52 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 
















