Who Would You Rather Have?

If we don’t take Vontae — odds are Jason Allen or gulp Eric Green would be starting right now.

And we don’t win today.

I picked Vontae. Tough to say though, because I think if we had Britt instead of Davis, we’d all probably vote for Britt in this poll..

Three picks as a rookie. I expected Smith to be more of a ball-hawk than Vontae this year, but three interceptions (including a pick six) says a hell of a lot about a trial-by-fire type of season.

QBs barely throw at Smith and Vontae picks off some of the balls that do come his way. Paul Pasqueloni REALLY needs to learn how to double-cover the right receiver, and once we get a DC who knows how to coach these guys up the right way (and they’re given time to adjust and learn), we will be unthrowable (?) against.

Receiver is an area of concern for us, but Vontae has completely lived up to the expectations that came with the #25 overall pick.

If I had told you before this season that Vontae would pick Tom Brady in both our games against New England, would you have believed me?

As of now, Vontae was absolutely the right pick at #25. He’s already a huge part of our defense.

He is fantastic against the run (Winfield good)

He lines up against other teams best WR and still holds his own. I’m just waiting for next year when Vontae will be attacking WR’s and not the other way around.

Vontae’s hands are VERY good. Everyone of his INT’s were very difficult passes to intercept. Taking the ball right from under Randy Moss is no easy feat.

I am loving this pick of course. Now its up to Sean Smith to step up big time and show what he can do. He is the guy that looks like a rookie out there. He is in perfect coverage usually but never seems to turn his head around fast enough to see the ball. Hopefully he can make this adjustment and have a great rest of the year

This is nothing against Davis, because honestly I like him and the future is bright at the CB position, but if you would’ve asked me during draft day it would have been Britt. If you would ask me right now, It’ll still be Britt. Ask me again in 10 years..still probably would be Britt.

I feel like we are going to address the WR position this off-season. We really do have a great supporting cast in WR but we still need that #1 threat. I like Britt, but when you can get a carrer corner, I say take him, and we did. Actually we got two. I say great pick up.

V. Davis is one of the two or three most talented CB’s in the league. He’s already beginning to put it together. Save for Moss’s big TD catch (Wilson’s fault – not Davis’s), he shut down Randy.

Britt might be a very good WR. He’s not yet. Davis is already a very good CB. There are WR’s in this next draft that I like a good deal better than Britt. If we don’t land a FA, we can go after them.

but i will keep davis. I think it is easier to find a #1 WR than a true starting caliber CB.

questions like this. It’s as bad as a “what if” question.