The Phinsider: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: UNC 77, Ohio State 73

Great Returners, Great Receivers, and Ted Ginn

So, listening to the radio today, all of the “Ted Ginn the returner vs. Ted Ginn the receiver” talk got me thinking.  I couldn’t name a single game-changing return man who was also a game-changing receiver.  To verify this, I looked at Pro-Football-Reference.com to see if there are any players dating back to 1994 with multiple return touchdowns who also led their team in receptions, receiving yards, or receiving TDs in the same year.  This is what I found:

2008: Johnnie Lee Higgins - 3 punt return TDs, led Raiders with 4 receiving TDs.

2007: Nate Burleson - 1 punt return TD, 1 kickoff return TD, led Seahawks with 9 receiving TDs.

2003: Brian Westbrook - 2 punt return TDs., led Eagles with 4 receiving TDs.

2002: Steve Smith - 2 punt return TDs, led Panthers with 872 receiving yards.

2001: Troy Brown - 2 punt return TDs, led Patriots in receptions, yards, and TDs with 101/1199/5.

1998: Joey Galloway - 2 punt return TDs, led Seahawks in receptions, yards, and TDs with 65/1047/10.

1998: Jermaine Lewis - 2 punt return TDs, led Ravens in receiving yards and TDs with 784/6.

1996: Eddie Kennison - 2 punt return TDs, led the Rams in receiving TDs with 9.  

 

If I didn't list a year, it's because nobody met the criteria that year.  Off the bat, we can ignore Brian Westbrook because he’s a RB, not a WR.  Out of the remaining players, only Steve Smith and Joey Galloway had multiple 1,000 yard receiving seasons and only Steve Smith made multiple Pro Bowls as a receiver.  Let’s call those 2 players both game-changing returners and game-changing receivers.  That’s 2 players in the past 15 years that have been both.

 

Complicating the analysis are the following notable players:

-Santana Moss returned 2 punts for TDs in 2002 (his second season) and later on had 3 1000-yard seasons.

-Randy Moss returned 1 punt and 1 kick for TDs in 2003.  He’s arguably a first-round Hall-of-Famer.

-1996 Rookie Amani Toomer had 2 punt return TDs and was #1 quality for the Giants later in his career with 5 straight 1000-yard receiving seasons.

-1994 Robert Brooks of the Packers had multiple return TDs and eventually had 2 1000-yard receiving seasons.

 

These players were arguably game-changing returners earlier in their careers and became game-changing receivers later on in their careers.

 

So what conclusions can we draw from this?  This is what I can come up with:

 

1. Coaches do not let their game-changing wide receivers return kicks and punts, even if they are game-changing returners as well.

 

This is obvious.  With the exception of Randy Moss in 2003, all of the players I mentioned as both game-changing receivers and game-changing returners made the lion’s share of their multiple 1,000-yard seasons or Pro Bowls AFTER they had their multiple return TD seasons.  This means that, potentially, many of the game-changing WRs out there would also be game-changing returners given the chance (I mean, who wouldn’t love to see Andre Johnson or Reggie Wayne returning kicks?)

 

2.  Players with the body type to be great returners are generally not big enough to be great receivers.

 

            This becomes clearer when you look at some of the WRs who consistently showed up as multiple return-TD scorers in the last 15 years.  For example: Devin Hester (5’10”, 185), Tamarick Vanover (6’, 220), Dante Hall (5’8” 187), Josh Cribbs (6’1, 192), Desmond Howard (5’10, 185), Mel J. Gray (5’9”, 167) are/were all great returners, but not great receivers.  Contrast this with the top receivers from that time: Randy Moss (6’4”, 215), Larry Fitzgerald (6’3”, 225), Isaac Bruce (6’, 188), Jerry Rice (6’2”, 200), Michael Irvin (6’2”, 207), Terrell Owens, (6’3”, 226), Tim Brown (6’, 195), and Marvin Harrison (6’, 175).  For the most part, the great returners are under 6’ and under 200 lbs (biggest exception being Tamarick Vanover) and the great receivers, regardless of weight,  are at least 6’ tall.  This suggests that Steve Smith (5’9”, 185) is the exception, not the rule. 

 

3.  Ted Ginn-related conclusions

 

            Ted Ginn is not a game-changing receiver.  This isn’t a shocker.  Statistically, at 5’11”, 178, he does not have the size to be a game-changing receiver.  To anyone who has watched him drop passes over and over again the last few years, this is no revelation.  However, he is the perfect size for a game-changing returner.  Thus, I wouldn’t advocate cutting him from the roster completely this offseason unless his salary makes it absolutely necessary.

            More interesting to me is that Coach Sparano and staff have continued to let Ginn return kicks.  Since it seems that, in the last 15 years, coaches do not want their great receivers returning kicks, this shows that the Dolphins do not see Ginn as a #1 receiver.  Again, this may be obvious by the fact that Ginn didn’t start this last game.  However, the benching can be seen as a motivational ploy.  A willingness to expose Ginn to injury by allowing him to return kicks cannot be explained as anything other than a realization that Ginn is not going to be a game-changing receiver.  Look for the Dolphins to either sign a WR who fits the body type of the majority of great receivers (Brandon MarshallSteve Breaston?) or to draft one in an early round (Brandon LaFell from LSU?  Arrelious Benn from Illinois?  Eric Decker from Minnesota?). 

 

Finally, I have way too much time on my hands.  And most importantly, GO DOLPHINS!!!

This fanpost was written by one of The Phinsider's registered users.

0 recs  |  Comment 7 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Tim Brown

I don’t think Tim Brown was a great returner. He didn’t make it into my analysis because he never scored multiple return touchdowns in the same year. In fact, in his whole 17-year career, he only returned 4 kicks for TDs. Yardage-wise, he was decent but not great. In his 5 best punt returning seasons where he returned more than 20 punts, he ranked 4th (1994), 5th (1993), 4th (1991), 9th (1992), and 14th (1995) in yards per return. Interestingly, he did lead the league in yards per kickoff return in 1988, but didn’t score multiple touchdowns and never returned more than 5 kickoffs in a season again. Looking at how he did as a punt returner, I’d say 1988 may have been a fluke.

That being said, Tim Brown was definitely a Hall of Fame quality receiver. He also supports my size theory since he was 6’ and 195 lbs.

by Saxonthebeach on Nov 2, 2009 5:18 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

interesting post

likes it!

Confidence breeds success, self-doubt breeds failure

by Blaze453 on Nov 2, 2009 4:31 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

good post

but we definitely getting a receiver in the 2nd round of the draft or at least i hope so Golden Tate anyone. Anyways Ted Ginn could be a game changing receiver i doubt it but the way he was on that field he would be amazing on screens and drags

Who DAT: WILDCAT
DOA= DEAD ON ARRIVAL

by DPL3 Rollin on Nov 2, 2009 7:14 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SB Nation's community dedicated to the only franchise in NFL history to have an undefeated team: the Miami Dolphins!
Start posting about the Dolphins »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

P7152587_small
Gameday Story In Pictures: Medic Edition
Mhtd-avatar_small
Coast to Coast With MHTD
101_2268_small
A tailgate / gameday story in pictures. Part 2
Dscn1715_small
2009 Perspective VIII
Small
Pat Tillman.....in honor of Veterans Day

Recent FanPosts

Fishfin_small
My Gameday Adventure - Volume 1
Meeee_small
Some Pics From The Game Last Night
Dolphinschick_small
Question regarding our Wide Outs
Snapshot_20091120_2_small
Miami Dolphins Player Pick 'Em Contest - Week 11 vs Carolina
Small
Patrick Turner?!?!?!
Mike1_small
Going to the Bills-Dolphins game on Nov 29
Small
Can we put the Bess mess to rest?
Seansmith03-194x300_small
Porter More Effective with Additional Rest?
101_2268_small
You Can't Make this stuff up ; Living in Dolphin Heaven !
Brandon_london_2_small
Lousaka For Pres

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Mobile Live
Eagles shuffle linebackers again
Mobile Live
The VRR: Redskins (3-6) @ Cowboys (6-3)
Mobile Live
Antonio Pierce out indefinitely

SPONSORS


Managers

Phinsider_s_small Matty I