This team plus the qbs,Just cant stay consistant for some reason…One day the offense does good next is the defense…I believe that we have a big surprise if we keep it up like this.

Beck has been able to string together a few good practices, each day this week. I think this says good things about him as he looked to have come out tight last week, and played awefull. He could have folded and tanked it this week, but has shown the ability to bounce back. Might be important with the poor weeks this team will no doubt have this year… Either way, good on him!

Beck fumbled a snap AGAIN today with Satele. What the f**k is his problem? He looks good otherwise, but come on! We don’t need a turnover in the red zone when the game is on the line b/c of an elementary play. He should be practicing snaps every morning and evening instead of throwing 7,000 times.

When Beck fumbles a single snap in practice it’s the end of the world but when Henne the savior fumbles a snap, throws two interceptions and looks particularly bad in a practice no one is there to criticize him. Everyone needs to just shut their traps and let all these guys play. If everyone hasn’t noticed but JOHN BECK not Henne or McCown has been playing superbly this week. But it seems that no one can let Beck forget his first week of practice. Has anyone even considered that because of the new throwing mechanics that he has implemented it took him about a week to get used to it in a practice and playing situation.

I hope Beck wins the starting job and beat Favre and the Jets the opening week and then leads the Phins to a 9 win season.

I misread who posted the “Beck the Fumbler” comment.
It should read “Gophish what’s your deal…” :)

All i have to say is that I hate Bill Parcells more now then I did 4 hours ago with this whole pennington BS….I really Can not stand Bill Parcells and I truely feel sorry for beck….If I was him I would demand a trade because Bill Parceels does not deserve a QB like John Beck

Seems like he has a lot going against him at this point. I feel like I am rooting for an underdog at this point. First and foremost, I am a phins fan, but I am rooting for this kid to succeed. Best case scenario for me, is that he succeeds leading the fins.

Look folks, I am not a Beck or McCown or Henne fan. I want the best QB who gives us a chance to win to line up behind center and take the snaps.

Lets look at this. With McCown, you know what you are getting. He will probably throw 9-10 TD’s in a full season and the same number of INT’s. His best year was 2004 with Arizona where he threw for 2500 yds, 11 TD’s and 10 INT’s in 14 games. You know what you are getting with him, he has a track record. He has shown nothing this camp that says this is his breakout year for him. (Granted, lets wait until the games start up and see how it goes) Fact is though, you know what you are getting with McCown and its not pretty.

Henne is a rook and you just drafted him, so he is staying, no arguments.

Beck is the wild card. You have no idea at all what you are getting with him. He played in all of 5 games last year, was thrown to the wolves by an inept coaching staff with an extremely complicated system and a weak O-Line. This year you have a vanilla offensive system in place, he is starting to show signs of coming around and playing a little faster, he is 3 years younger than McCown, etc.

Bring in Pennington, keep Beck and Henne and let the two of them learn behind Chad and see if either one is ready to take the reigns next year. You have 2 QB’s who have no real track record, but have potential, and you have 1 QB who really “is what he is” in McClown…

This is pure common sense folks, nothing more, nothing less. You are not going to the Super Bowl this year, you are building a team for the future, have plenty of picks next year, etc. You don’t want to completely ruin Henne or Beck’s future by throwing them in this year when they are not ready, etc. Let them learn.

THAT, is the hard reality of the NFL.