We set the price higher than his value, and the interested party offers less than his value, and the two sides bicker but eventually meet in the middle.

If there’s a team out there (the ’boys?) willing to get fleeced out of a fourth, fifth, or even a sixth for Beck, Ireland should and probably will take it.

looks in NE,after THREE years of getting ALL the extra snaps behind a very good OL,then why in the hell would anyone consider ANYONE a “bust” after less than the same amount of time with less to work with?

Beck looked pretty good in a lot of situations against Philly and Pitt. last year before he realized that this WASNT the BYU OL he had grown accustomed to and that he would be facing 7 and 8 in the box EVERY play because of our OL and the lack of weapons.

A good team with a good OL will pick him up and he may very well play himself into at least a back-up roll IF he doesnt see ghosts for the rest of his career…I’m sure a lot of good players have been ruined by lack of trust in their supporting cast and I’m just thankful that Henne wont have to suffer these SAME circumstances.

to get a 4th. It would be a good deal for both teams, most likely. He doesnt fit what the Fins want to do but he could still develop somewhere else where he makes sense(ie a West Coast offense team).

There is NO " logic" to one team STILL “grooming” an obvious bum with a dream job but another one giving up on a 5 game player with a laughable supporting cast.

Do you pick up what Im putting down now?..if not then bless your little heart.

He definetly needs to go somewhere else because Cam all but ruined him.

Im not a fan of starting rookie QB’s because of this very example BUT Henne would be fine to start because he came from a team that gave him time plus he had weapons and now Miami can give him time and we have weapons so the NFL game wont be such a shock to him and he can just be a QB and adjust to the speed etc. because he can STILL trust those around him like he did at Michigan.

How anyone thinks they can judge Beck based on last years performance is mind boggling. If Beck has blown his opportunity it happened this spring/summer – not from last year – at least it shouldn’t have.

To give up on Beck after last seasons performance is the height of stupidity.
If you weren’t doing well at your job because of the team around and the management, wouldn’t you feel slightly aggrieved.
He’s come into a new team, with new management and apart from the first week of training camp is performing the same as Henne and McCown. Just like the rest of us, if somebody switched the system you worked in the boss you worked for and a lot of the people who worked with then you’d take some time to adjust and then you’d get better.
I’m not saying start it him, but its got to be better than a couple of bad days at the office, oh well lets get rid of him.
If we were all judged the same way that people have judged Beck then we’d all be changing jobs. I’m just wondering how long it will take before everyone turns on Henne!
This might call for a poll if I can ever work out how to do it. How long before the Miami faithful turn on Henne and demand the management draft or trade for a QB with another 1st or 2nd round pick?

might as well ask for the stars and hope to get the moon…er…or something like that

You wrote :

"I disagree!

Using my job as an example…my job (ala being a quarterback) would not change just because of mangement or fellow employees. I would still have to do the shipping/recieveing/invetory things that I do now…how I report what I do might change but the physical day to day work wouldnt change becuase there is a finite definition to the job at hand. With a quarterback you can be rusty or make mistakes because of the system…but the system doesnt dictate how you physically throw the ball or your demeanor in the pocket. Beck just doesnt have the SELF-Confidince that Henne shows NOR the physical presense. I have seen the difference in the line play and how the guys hustle back to the huddle when either of the chads are in but they dont seem to give a shit when john or josh are in there. Now granted that was only the first preseason game but hey its obvious as orange and teal to me that everyone is lifted when either of the chads are in the huddle.."

Your analogy is assuming that your prior supporting cast,starting with the “Scheduler”(Head Coach), wasnt a bunch of crackheads and as the “Warehouse Manager”(QB) you were not only trying to do your job but you have to deal with those around you ,that directly effect your ability to do your job, constantly Fing up their job and that in turn makes you look like an idiot !

Say for instance that your “scheduler” constantly overlapped freight arrival times and assigns them to the same dock door and that the receiving department constantly brought the trucks into the wrong dock door to be unloaded and that IF per adventure they did get them in the correct door the forklift driver without fail would damage some of the freight on every load he attempted to off load on to the dock.

You FINALLY get the freight to the correct door and FINALLY got it offloaded onto the dock only to find out that your crackhead “Inventory Clerk” had his head up his ass and ordered 1k more cases of product (A) of which you already have 10k in stock and (0) cases of product (B) of which you have none of.

You would have ZERO confidence in those around you and until the “new group” proved they werent a bunch of crackheads like your last co-workers,you would be constantly expecting the worst and would assume that the trucks would be staged wrong,the freight would get damaged and that you didnt need half the freight you did receive and would need more of what you didnt receive.

THANK GOD that the new “Warehouse Manager”(Henne) came from a well managed Warehouse and is coming into a work environment where his new co-workers had to pass a drug screen BEFORE being hired,have a GOOD track record and are more than capable of doing their job and now ALL he has to do is sit back in his comfortable chair in his Air Conditioned office and have the comfort of knowing that the other workers around him are doing their jobs correctly.

I dont know if Beck would have ever been able to excel in the NFL,he seemed to be bright and have a lot of the tools you look for in a QB prospect BUT now I dont think we ever will and it doesnt matter because PIS have guaranteed that Henne will have a smooth transition into the NFL and he should Thank God EVERY minute of EVERY day that he came to Miami when he did and NOT when he wouldve been surrounded by a bunch of crackheads.

THAT far so maybe you would see just how flawed YOUR “analogy” was.

“Bottom line, Henne looks to be the much better option at this point than Beck.”

Bottom line…I wouldnt expect anything less.