The Phinsider: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:





Day One Draft Nuggets

What a crazy day Saturday turned out to be.  And after a few hours of getting out and not thinking about football, I think I can now better reflect on what the Dolphins did (and didn't do) on Saturday.  And I must say, I really like the direction this team is headed.  Onto a few quick nuggets:

IRELAND'S PRESS BRIEFING

The most intriguing issue of today, the decision to not trade Jason Taylor, is the first thing I want to point out.  About the trade rumors that circulated all day, Jeff Ireland said:

“I was not aware of it. I was aware of it after the fact, but obviously strictly rumor. Didn’t get any calls, so there was no discussion [of trading Taylor]."

Interesting, to say the least, especially when you consider the seemingly endless supply of rumors over the past 48 hours.  But hey, if they didn't get any offers (or at least any they liked), then I'm glad Jason Taylor is still a Dolphin.  No need to just "give him away" for poor value, right?

Other interesting tidbits from Ireland's press briefing:

(On what the selection of Henne means to Beck)
"John's got a quick release, a strong arm, and he's highly competitive. You never have enough of those guys. It’s gonna bring some competition to the position. We like both these kids, Josh McCown as well, so it’s gonna be a good battle for these guys. We like John. This has no bearing on whether we like John or don’t like John or anything like that. We’re in the business of collecting good football players, and that’s what we’ve done."

(On what he likes about Henne)
"He’s a four year starter at the University of Michigan — I like that. He’s a great leader, and he’s got an aura about him that you like about a quarterback. And in doing my homework, he had nine come-from-behind fourth quarter wins in his career, and I think that was more than any quarterback we studied."

(On the trade of Lorenzo Booker to the Eagles)
"I don’t think he really fit our system that we’re trying to put in place here. We fielded a call pretty early in the process about him, and he’s a great kid, he’s a playmaker, but at the end of the day he didn’t really fit this system that we’re putting in place here."

SALGUERO THINKS BECK IS IN TROUBLE

In his latest blog entry, the Herald's Armando Salguero writes that he thinks the selection of Chad Henne is a clear message to John Beck.  Salguero writes:

Beck is not a Parcells guy. Parcells didn't scout him, didn't draft him, didn't sign him. And that makes Beck the only one of Miami's three quarterbacks that Parcells did not pick or scout or sign. Parcells inherited Beck from the previous regime while he went out and got Josh McCown as a free agent and drafted Chad Henne Saturday.

So that puts Beck at a disadvantage. Henne and McCown are not going to get a free ride by any means, but I do believe they rate higher than Beck in the mind of Parcells -- because they were picked by Parcells.

That means any tie on any matter goes to McCown and Henne. And not Beck. For Beck to win the coming quarterback competition -- assuming he's even in the competition, by the way -- he's going to have to outplay the other two.

Give me a break, Armando.  The most negative Dolphins' beat writer strikes again!

John Beck is still clearly in Miami's plans.  He's going to come into camp and compete to start just like Josh McCown and Chad Henne are.  And no matter who actually brought these players in, the best player will earn the starting job.  And right now, my money is on John Beck.  I know for a fact that John has been working insanely hard this offseason and that he's had a chip on his shoulder all offseason.  Now, that chip only gets larger.  For a guy like John, this will not discourage him; it will only act to motivate him some more.

Don't get me wrong; I'm not hoping Henne fails or anything.  I just want to win football games.  And I firmly believe that John will show that he does give this team the best chance to win games, not just in 2008, but also beyond. 

With that said, though, let the competition begin!  It gives us, as diehard fans, something to keep a close eye on all camp and preseason long.  It will surely be an entertaining battle.  May the best man win!

MERLING TO BE DE, NOT OLB

Omar Kelly points out something that I believed from the moment Phillip Merling was drafted at #32.  He's not a potential replacement for Jason Taylor in Miami's 3-4 defense.  No, he's going to battle for a starting DE spot:

Merling will likely push Vonnie Holliday and Matt Roth for a starting spot. Maybe not immediately, but in time. And his addition likely means Randy Starks is the primary backup to Jason Ferguson at nose tackle unless one is added on Sunday.

Dolphins General Manager Jeff Ireland said the Trifecta wasn't concerned at all about his sports hernia. Defensive line coach Kacy Rodgers went to check him out at his workout earlier this week and liked what he saw. They picked Merling over Auburn's Quentin Groves, who would have been more suited to serve as an outside linebacker. Merling is a straight 3-4 end.

I've thought for a while that this upcoming year was a big one for both Matt Roth and Vonnie Holliday.  Not only will Randy Starks now be pushing them (he can play all 3 spots along the DL in a 3-4), but now a talented player like Merling will come in here and push to start.  Personally, I think it's Matt Roth who needs to be worried the most.

So that's it for now.  We'll have much, much more in the coming days and weeks about all the events of this weekend.

Be sure to join us here again tomorrow for more "live" coverage of day 2 of the NFL Draft.  Look for the open thread to be posted around 9:30 am.

See you all then.

0 recs | Comment 8 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

NFL site

I really enjoy the NFL’s website coverage of the draft prospects; however, maybe it’s just my computer, but I have not been able to access the analysis section of any of the prospects – anybody else having problems with the site?

by CJS55 on Apr 27, 2008 8:18 AM EDT   0 recs

I think Armando was correct, just a little off target.

He should have said “Beck is in trouble if he doesn’t come in and perform well right away.” Again, back to the age disadvantage that Beck has when referring to young QB’s. I think that if Beck comes in and doesn’t show he is ready to take the starting job, that this regime could very well discard him pretty quickly, for the reason that Armando said…he’s not a BP pick. I view Henne as a 2 year project, at the minimum.

I don’t see Holliday being here more than this year, and at the most next year. They need to find new, young DE’s between this draft and next year’s draft. Roth I’m kind of in the middle on. He’s never realized the potential of being a 2nd round pick, but he’s still only 25. The most sacks he’s had was the the 3 he had last year. He needs to have a very good year this year or he may get discarded by this regime, or at best, become a career back-up.

by dab415217 on Apr 27, 2008 8:53 AM EDT   0 recs

Clearly, if the Dolphins did not think highly of Beck, they would have taken Henne at 32. There was no way they could have expected him to be there at 57, and if they didn’t believe they had a QB already in place, they would have addressed that at 32, if not at #1 overall with Matt Ryan.

Obviously, Henne was too good value in their opinion to pass on at 57, and in any case, Beck is not a sure thing, so they can use a good fallback option at QB.

But Beck will start this year and get all the chances. If he fails, Henne will take over. If not, good QBs retain their value for years, so if Henne is any good, this will never be a wasted pick.

by icerob on Apr 27, 2008 9:37 AM EDT   0 recs

I see it differently.

A true vote of confidence would have been picking a player at a position of “need” with #57. Picking a filler/project QB in the 4th round or later would have told me there was a true belief that Beck was the future at QB. Remember pre-draft that some were predicting that Henne could go at the end of round 1. Yes, he was a good value at 57, but if Beck WAS the guy in Parcells eyes there wouldn’t have been a need to pick Henne.

by dab415217 on Apr 27, 2008 10:00 AM EDT to parent up   0 recs

That’s just what I mean: it’s not a true vote of confidence, but it’s not a “not our guy” message, either. Beck will get first crack at the job, and if and when he fails, Henne will get a shot.

Some were saying Henne could go at the end of round 2, but I think most had him going early in the second or even late in the first.

by icerob on Apr 27, 2008 10:25 AM EDT to parent up   0 recs

I agree with Dab...

and by extension, actually Salguero.

Beck is not a Parcells guy. This regime has zero ties to Beck, they didn’t pick him, they didn’t sign him, nor are they staking their reputation or future to Beck.

If the Dolphins just wanted someone to ‘compete’ they could have brought in a 35 year old backup plus some say, 5th round QB they drafted. If they had drafted say Dennis Dixon or Josh Johnson or Andre Woodson or geez, even Colt Brennan, then I’d say yeah, Beck is the guy. In such a scenario, Beck would definitely be ‘the starter’ and not be looking over his shoulder.

The dolphins do not ‘need’ a mere backup QB or more competition at QB – they already brought in a younger guy, in McCown to do just that.

Instead of helping a secondary with big problems they opted for Henne. Why would you draft Henne, on a 1-15 team with tons of needs, to just hold a clipboard and be a backup for very long?

by Natalya on Apr 28, 2008 2:18 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

sad to say I agree

nat is exactly right, i’m sorry to say because I like Beck….

But you can only have one QB of the future on a team.

C’est la Vie John Beck

by W NY Fins Fan on Apr 28, 2008 11:50 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

what does the dolphins got a head coach for?

I realy dont see why the miami dolphins got a head coach for he plays no role on this team and what they do.Bill controls and demands what happens to this team and everybody else is just kiss asses that are in it for the ride.Like when tony was talken about how the dolphins were gonna work with lorenzo booker and make him a speacil key in this team as he was.A month later what happend and this ant the first,So i believe they have no say and what ever comes out of the mouth from jeff or tony dont believe shit. With bill i like what hes doen and hes realy turnen this team around but what he did with lorenzo was stupid just because he wasnt big and strong enough.There more to a player then just that,He was one of the only players as a rookie steped in and played a good role on this team last year and had a lot of heart and loved to play here.On third down he always came threw and was injury free and also can brake some knees…....... Bill also needs to learn if you got a good weapon on your team dont just throw him away cuz hes not your type of player learn how to fit him in your system….........................................

by lionel on Apr 28, 2008 4:20 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SB Nation's blog dedicated to the only franchise in NFL history to have an undefeated team: the Miami Dolphins!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Jason Taylor Traded
Florida-gators-2_small
Injury leads to trade talk
Dolphins_small
Fins battles entering camp
Florida-gators-2_small
Our "Needy" Spots
Small
BIRTHDAY: PART 2
Huminomaax-man5_small
Cadillac, Benson and Brown
Picture_001_small
Please help, thank you
Football_ball1_www
2008 Week 11: Raiders at Dolphins 1 pm
Football_ball1_www
2008 Week 12: Patriots at Dolphins 1 pm
Football_ball1_www
2008 Week 13: Dolphins at St. Louis 1pm

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Phinsider160_small Matty I

ad

Site Meter